R. v. TANG KAM WING

CACC000465/1992

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL,

1992 No 465

(Criminal)

____________

BETWEEN
THE QUEEN
and
TANG KAM WING

____________

Coram: Hon Kempster and Macdougall, JJA

Date of hearing: 15 January 1993

Date of judgment: 15 January 1993

_______________

J U D G M E N T

_______________

Kempster, JA:

1. This is the judgment of the Court.

2. On 16 October 1992, after trial in the District Court, Tang Kam-wing was convicted by His Honour Judge Longley of handling stolengoods and on 30th of that month, having considered a Probation Report, the judge sentenced him to 2 years’ imprisonment. Againstthat sentence he seeks leave to appeal on the grounds that such sentence was unfair.

3. The “goods” handled, on 28 January 1991, were 19 share certificates of Hutchison Whampoa Ltd. They disappeared from the premisesof stockbrokers Hoare Govett (Hong Kong) Ltd during January 1990. Wheelock Marden & Co issued replacement certificates and thosethat had disappeared were declared null and void.

4. The applicant “handled” the Hutchison Whampoa certificates by producing them to and instructing the North Point Branch of the ChiyuBank to sell them. This was done by the Bank without checking the list of lost instruments and the applicant’s account was creditedwith the sum of $247,269.40; which sum he immediately withdrew in cash.

5. Although the applicant did not have a clear record this was his first conviction for dishonesty since 1978. The judge took into accountthe facts that he was being used by others and that his wife had left him. He sentenced him accordingly. We are happy to learn thathis wife has now determined to stand by him and that he feels remorse for what he did. However, we see no grounds warranting interferencewith the sentence. The application for leave to appeal against it is refused.

(Michael Kempster) (Neil Macdougall)
Justice of Appeal Justice of Appeal

Representation:

C.D.F. Coghlan (Senior Crown Counsel) for the Crown

Applicant in person